Teacher Documentation (K12)

Evaluate discussions

In the Discussions tool, you can review and evaluate discussion topics and individual participants without changing your workflow.

New Discussion Evaluation Experience

The new Discussion Evaluation Experience is part of a redesign of all assessable tools. The new experience allows instructors to better review and evaluate both discussion topics and individual participants, without changing their workflow.

The New Discussion Evaluation Experience includes the following features:

The name of the activity, navigation arrows, and student name and profile card appear in the header panel at the top.
The discussion topic and replies appear in the submission panel on the left. The title of the topic or the reply is a link that will open the post in a new window so you can get an idea of the context in which the post was made.
Evaluation tools like Grades, Rubrics, Grading Rubric, and Feedback appear in the evaluation panel on the right. When you open the Inline Rubric, it expands within the panel or pops out into a new window for grading.
You can drag the divider between the submission panel and the evaluation panel to resize them to suit your preferences and screen size. The divider stays in the same position as you navigate through your students' submissions.
In adaptive mobile view, the evaluation tools are hidden in a drawer at the bottom of the screen. Tap the drawer to display the tools.

Mobile view of discussion evaluation.

Figure: Use mobile view to evaluate discussions.

Link a discussion assessment to a grade item

Link a discussion topic to a grade item to grade students based on their participation or knowledge in your course. Discussions are a great way to interact and engage with your students and allow them to practice demonstrating their knowledge.

Make a discussion topic gradable and link it to a grade item

When you add a discussion topic’s score to a numeric grade item in your grade book, your students' scores automatically transfer to the grade book. This enables you to factor the topic score into their final grades for the course.

This is the paper note and pencil icon used for notes.

Note: You can only link numeric grade items to discussion topics.

To make a discussion topic gradable and link it to a grade item

You can edit an existing topic or create a new discussion topic:
- Navigate to Discussions. In the Actions menu for a discussion topic, click Edit Topic.
  Figure: Click Edit Topic in the context menu for an assignment.
- Navigate to Content. In the module where you want to create your discussion topic, click Create New > Discussion.
  
  Figure: Click Discussion on the What would you like to create? page.
On the topic creation or edit page, enter a numeric value in Grade Out Of.
Figure: Enter a value in the Grade Out Of field.
In the Grade Out Of section, click the drop-down menu and click Edit or Link to Existing.
Figure: Click the drop-down menu and then click Edit or Link to Existing.
In the Edit or Link to Existing dialog, select one of the following:
- Select Create and link to a new grade item to create a new grade item associated with your discussion topic. Choose the Grade Scheme for your new grade item.
- Select Link to an existing grade item to link your discussion topic to an existing grade item. Select the existing grade item from the drop-down list.
Click OK.
Figure: Create a new grade item link or link to an existing grade item.
Toggle the Visibility of your discussion topic to be Visible or Hidden.
Click Save and Close.
Figure: Make your topic Visible or Hidden and then click Save and Close.

Your discussion topic is now linked to a grade item.

Assess a discussion topic

You must publish the score for Brightspace to update the grade item in the grade book. This prevents the display of inaccurate grades before you finish assessing users. When you publish the topic score, Brightspace updates the grade item in the grade book, and makes the grade visible to students in Discussions, Content, and User Progress. Any additional changes you make to a user’s score automatically updates in the grade book.

To assess a discussion topic

Navigate to Discussions.
From the Actions menu of the topic you want to assess, click Assess Topic.
Figure: Click Assess Topic from the Actions menu.

On the Assess Topic page, do one of the following:

To publish scores for specific students, select Draft in the Status column beside each student whose score you want to release. Click Save.
To publish scores for all students, click Publish > Yes.

Note: You cannot publish or save your draft if the Overall Feedback field exceeds 300,000 characters. If the Overall Feedback field exceeds the character limit or if the Grade field contains an invalid grade, a dialog pops up and the tooltip "There is one or more errors in the information entered appears" when you try to save or publish.

Assessment methods available for a discussion

If you have allow evaluation of individual posts (under Evaluate Posts) selected, any grades you enter in Grade Book for discussion grade items are also synchronized back to Discussions. This change ensures data consistency between Discussions and Grade Book.

Note: Currently, Discussion grades are not synchronized when the Discussion tool is updated by the Brightspace API or when Grade Book is exported and imported.

The following calculation methods are available to assess discussions.

Calculation method	Definition
Average post score	This calculation method averages all of the post scores included per user.
Maximum post score	This calculation method identifies the highest score of all the post scores included per user.
Minimum post score	This calculation method identifies the lowest score of all the post scores included per user.
Mode post score - Highest on multiple	This calculation method looks at the frequency of scores on posts, then selects the highest occurrence of a score per user. Once it picks the frequency, the system looks to see if multiple scores occur at that frequency. If not, it assigns that score to the user. If there are multiple scores with the same frequency, it will choose the highest of those scores. For example, if a score of 7 occurs 2 times, a score of 8 occurs 3 times, and a score of 9 occurs 3 times, the system will choose the frequency 3 and the score of 9.
Mode post score - Lowest on multiple	This calculation method looks at the frequency of scores on posts, then selects the highest occurrence of a score per user. Once it picks the frequency, the system looks to see if multiple scores occur at that frequency. If not, it assigns that score to the user. If there are multiple scores with the same frequency, it will choose the lowest of those scores. For example, if a score of 7 occurs 2 times, a score of 8 occurs 3 times, and a score of 9 occurs 3 times, the system will choose the frequency 3 and the score of 8.
Sum of post scores	This calculation method sums up all the scores on posts within a topic.

Video: How to grade a discussion in your grade book

<br>

Evaluate discussions using the Discussions tool

You can drag the divider between the submission and evaluation panels to resize them to suit your preferences and screen size. The divider stays in the same position as you navigate your students' submissions.

To evaluate a topic

On your course homepage, navigate to Discussions.

Figure: Click the Discussions tool on your course homepage.
On the Discussions List tab, select the Assess Topic option by clicking the drop-down menu next to the related topic's name.

Figure: In the topic context menu, click Assess Topic.
Once the new page has loaded that lists students who have posted a thread to the chosen topic, click Topic Score under a student's name.

Figure: Click Topic Score to begin assessing a student.
Once the thread has loaded in a new page, populate the following fields:
1. In the Overall Grade field, add the student's grade.
2. In the Overall Feedback field, add your comments or feedback.
3. Use the Attachments section to add text and audio-video files.
  Note: Students
  can review feedback files in the discussion or in the Grades tool.

Do one of the following:

Click Publish for the student to be notified of their activity grade.

Click Save as Draft to publish the grade and feedback later.

The discussion evaluation experience showing the Overall Grade and Overall Feedback fields and the Attachments section

Figure: Evaluate students on the evaluation page.

Note: When evaluating Discussion from the Evaluation page, you can click and drag the boundary between the Post pane and the Overall Feedback pane to change the size of each. If you reduce the size of the Overall Feedback pane past a break point, the icons change in appearance. The File Upload, Attach Link to Existing Activity, Attach Weblink, Attach from One Drive, Record Audio, and Record Video icons change to only show Attach, Record Audio, and Record Video icons as part of the adaptive experience. You can click Attach in this case to access the same options.

To evaluate a student:

On your course homepage, navigate to Discussions.
Figure: Click the Discussions tool on your course homepage.
On the Discussions List tab, select the topic you want to assess.

Figure: Select a topic from the Discussions List.
From the View Topic page, select the Assess Student option by clicking the drop-down menu next to the corresponding thread's name.

Figure: Click Assess Student in the drop-down menu.
Once the thread has loaded in a new page, populate the following fields:
1. In the Overall Grade field, add the student's grade.
2. In the Overall Feedback field, add your comments and feedback.
3. Use the Attachments section to add text and audio-video files.
  
  Note: Students
  can review feedback files in the discussion or in the Grades tool.

Do one of the following:

Click Publish for the student to be notified of their activity grade.

Click Save as Draft to publish the grade and feedback later.

The discussion evaluation experience showing the Overall Grade and Overall Feedback fields and the Attachments section

Figure: Evaluate students on the evaluation page.

Your grade will be published on the Assess Topic page.

The Topic Score on the Assess Topic page.

Figure: View the Topic Score on the Assess Topic page.

This is the lightbulb icon used for tips.

Tip: You can also evaluate both topics and students using the following way: From the View Topic page, click the needed thread and select the Assess Topic or Assess Student option next to this thread name.

Retract and re-publish assessments of discussions

You can retract published assessments from student view if you need to re-assess discussion posts. This option is available for individual users, or you can use the bulk retract and publishing features for larger numbers of users or the entire class.

Navigate to Discussions.
From the context menu of the topic you want to assess, click Assess Topic.
Select the checkbox next to a student's name and click Publish Feedback, or Retract Feedback.

Tip: Use the Status column to view information on when feedback was published, if a topic has not been evaluated, or if feedback is currently saved as a draft.

Video: Grade a Discussion Topic

<br>

Evaluate discussion topics

Use discussions to assess your students' knowledge and let them apply their learning from course content.

Navigate to Discussions.
On the Discussions List page, from the Actions menu of the topic you want to evaluate, click Assess Topic.
Figure: Click Assess Topic in the context menu.
Click the Topic Score link beneath the name of the user you want to assess. This will bring up all of their posts for the topic, which you can then assign either individual scores or an overall topic score for.

You have graded your students' discussion posts.

Assess individual discussion topic posts

Navigate to Discussions.
In the Actions menu of your discussion topic, click Edit Topic.
Figure: Click Edit Topic in the context menu.
On the Edit Topic page, expand the Evaluation & Feedback accordion.
Select Allow evaluation of individual posts. Select your Calculation Method.
Figure: Expand the Evaluation & Feedback accordion and select your calculation method.
Click Save and Close.
Figure: Change the topic's visibility and click Save and Close.

You have enabled the evaluation of individual posts for your discussion topic.

Evaluate discussions using the New Content Experience

In the Discussions tool, you can review and evaluate discussion topics and individual participants without changing your workflow.

Evaluate discussion topics and individual posts directly from the Content tool to avoid jumping back and forth between different tools in Brightspace.

To evaluate a topic

On your Content page, do one of the following:

Navigate to the lesson containing containing your discussion and click Go to Discussions.

Figure: Click Go to Discussion to view your discussion topic.
If you are using the assessable activity view, click Go to Topic.

Figure: Click Go to Topic in the activity view.

On the Discussions List tab, click the drop-down menu next to the related topic name and select Assess Topic.

Figure: The Assess Topic option in the drop-down menu.

Once the new page has loaded that lists users who have posted a thread to the chosen topic, click Topic Score under a student's name.

Figure: Click Topic Score under a student's name.

Once the thread has loaded in a new page, populate the following fields:

In the Overall Grade field, add the student's grade.
In the Overall Feedback field, add your comments or feedback.
Use the Attachments section to add text and audio-video files.
Note:
Students can review feedback files in the discussion or in the Grades tool.

Do one of the following:

Click Publish for the student to be notified of their activity grade.
Click Save as Draft to publish the grade and feedback later.

The discussion evaluation experience showing the Overall Grade and Overall Feedback fields and the Attachments section

Figure: Evaluate students on the evaluation page.
The discussion topic and replies appear in the submission panel on the left. The title of the topic or the reply is a link that opens the post in a new window so you can get an idea of the context in which the post was made. You can drag the divider between the submission and evaluation panels to resize them to suit your preferences and screen size. The divider stays in the same position as you navigate your students' submissions.

To evaluate a student:

On your Content page, do one of the following:
- Navigate to the lesson containing your discussion and click Go to Discussions.
  
  Figure: Click Go to Discussion to view your discussion topic.
- If you are using the assessable activity view, click Go to Evaluation in the Completion Summary section for the student you want to evaluate.
  
  Figure: Click Go to Evaluation in the Completion Summary section.
On the Discussions List tab, select the topic you want to assess.

Figure: Select a topic in the Discussions List tab.
From the View Topic page, select the Assess Student option by clicking the drop-down menu next to the corresponding thread's name.

Figure: Click Assess Student in the context menu
Once the thread has loaded in a new page, populate the following fields:
- In the Overall Grade field, add the student's' grade.
- In the Overall Feedback field, add your comments and feedback.
- Use the Attachments section to add text and audio-video files.
  Note:
  Students can review feedback files in the discussion or in the Grades tool.

Do one of the following:

Click Publish for the student to be notified of their activity grade.

Click Save as Draft to publish the grade and feedback later.

The discussion evaluation experience showing the Overall Grade and Overall Feedback fields and the Attachments section
Figure: Evaluate students on the evaluation page.

The discussion topic and replies appear in the submission panel on the left. The title of the topic or the reply is a link that opens the post in a new window so you can get an idea of the context in which the post was made. You can drag the divider between the submission and evaluation panels to resize them to suit your preferences and screen size. The divider stays in the same position as you navigate your students' submissions.

Your grade will be published on the Assess Topic page.

The Topic Score on the Assess Topic page.

Figure: View the Topic Score on the Assess Topic page.

Evaluate discussions using the Classic Content experience

In the Discussions tool, you can review and evaluate discussion topics and individual participants without changing your workflow.

Evaluate discussion topics and individual posts directly from the Content tool to avoid jumping back and forth between different tools in Brightspace.

To evaluate a topic:

On your Content page, navigate to the desired module that your discussion lives within and click on the title of the topic that you want to evaluate.
Figure: Click on the discussion topic in Content.
Figure: Click Assess Topic in the context menu.
On the Discussions List tab, select the Assess Topic option by clicking the drop-down menu next to the related topic's name.
Once the new page has loaded that lists users who have posted a thread to the chosen topic, click Topic Score under a student's name.

To evaluate a student:

On your Content page, navigate to the desired module that your discussion lives within and click on the title of the topic that you want to evaluate.
Figure: Click the discussion topic in Content.
On the Discussions List tab, select the topic you want to assess.

From the View Topic page, select the Assess Student option by clicking the drop-down menu next to the corresponding thread's name.

Once the thread has loaded in a new page, populate the following fields:
1. In the Overall Grade field, add the student's grade.
2. In the Overall Feedback field, add your comments and feedback. Use the Attachments section to add text and audio-video files.
  Note:
  Students can review feedback files in the discussion or in the Grades tool.

Do one of the following:

Click Publish for the student to be notified of their activity grade.

Click Save as Draft to publish the grade and feedback later.

The discussion evaluation experience showing the Overall Grade and Overall Feedback fields and the Attachments section
Figure: Evaluate students on the evaluation page.

As a result, your grade will be published on the Assess Topic page.

Figure: View the Topic Score on the Assess Topic page.

Video: Evaluate discussions

<br>